Sometimes the hype surrounding something can be built up to such an extent that the reality can’t match it. However, I was happy to find the salted caramel cookies way exceeded my expectations. So much so that I went back the next day to buy a couple more to take home with me. A good combination of flavour and texture making it one of the best cookies I have tried. Many other baked goods on offer if a salted caramel cookie isn’t your thing. Definitely a place I will re-visit the next time I am in Wellington.
I tried their mince and cheese pie and it was absolutely delicious. Although I had this to go, I’ll definitely stay and eat it there next time as the place is very cute. Staff was friendly—will definitely go back!
Such a lovely little cafe tucked into the mysterious Leeds Street alleyway. They have an extensive cabinet selection full of baked goods, sweet treats and prepared sandwiches, as well as coffee and specialty drinks.
The team were happy to customise a lamb leg sammie for me which was absolutely divine. Picture yourself at the dinner table on a Sunday night eating roast lamb with roast potatoes, veg, mint sauce etc - well think that + a kick of spice all sandwiched between two pieces of super seedy multigrain bread. We also grabbed the halloumi + chilli mayo sando which was full of sauce, maybe too much haha. I can’t fault the bread at Shelly Bay whatsoever, especially that seeded multigrain - it was to die for!
I will definitely be back for another lamb sandwich soon :)